Maintenance of Certification or Extortion?

I trained in internal medicine and cardiology at the tail end of the era of lifetime board certification by the American Board of Internal Medicine. In fact, my timing was perfect – I was “boarded” in medicine in 1987, and in cardiovascular disease in 1989, which (I am pretty sure) were, respectively, the last years that the ABIM offered certificates without an expiration date in those disciplines.

Late last year, I received a ABIM letter about my “enrollment status” in the ABIM’s maintenance of certification (MOC) program, which stated, among other things, that:

  •  I was not enrolled in the MOC program
  • My ABIM certifications were “valid indefinitely”
  • I could enroll in the MOC program in January, and by so doing, would hence forth be listed as “Certified, Meeting MOC Requirements”

I thought this all a bit strange. After all, how could there be MOC requirements if the certificate was “valid indefinitely?” I didn’t give it much thought until last week, when I tried to enroll. After a tedious registration process and a very long and somewhat annoying mandatory survey, followed by several more verification steps (medical school, NPI number and State license) I finally got to the enrollment page, where I was asked to provide credit card information to cover the annual $353 charge (including “applicable discounts”). Now I was really confused, so I called the ABIM.

After a bit of back and forth, here is what I learned:

  • Yes, my board certification is valid indefinitely
  • If I don’t “enroll” in the MOC program, I will be listed as “certified, not meeting MOC”
  •  I don’t have to actually do anything except pay the registration fee to be listed as “meeting MOC”

Does this make sense? I have no requirements, but if I don’t pay $353/year, I will be listed as not meeting requirements? What requirements? I thought I had a certificate that was valid indefinitely!

The only conclusion I could come to is that I was being shaken down by the ABIM, which was saying, in essence, that they would officially downgrade my status if I didn’t play ball and pay up. Whatever you think of MOC, this seems like nothing more than extortion to me.

What do you think?

3 thoughts on “Maintenance of Certification or Extortion?

  1. Ira,

    The perplexing part is that you do not have to actually perform a MOC activity to be listed as “meeting MOC requirements.” That is not my experience, so I am wondering if you were misinformed? If not, it is of course outrageous. In any event, the cost is also unnecessarily high.


  2. Hi Ira, one of my pet hates is being seen as the solution for the cash flow problems of the various regulatory and accreditation organisations we are expected to belong to (yes, it happens here too). The terminology is different in this part of the world, but what do you have to do to show ongoing competence to practice (CPD, peer review, audit, conferences, etc)?

Join the Discussion! Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s