Charlotte Nash

My mother died last week. This is about her.

She was born in New York City, raised as an only child on the Lower East Side, and was the proud product of city public schools and City College. She was an accomplished student and, as was common in those days, was accelerated through grade school, so that she graduated high school at the top of her class at age 16 and college at age 20. As was also common in those days, she married my father of blessed memory the same year she graduated from college, in August of 1949.

She and my father lived with her parents for a bit, with her teaching in the NYC public schools and then went off to Boston, where my father went to graduate school, and she taught 2nd grade in the Brookline public schools. When her father – a grandfather I never met, and for whom I am named – became ill, they moved back to NY, eventually becoming part of the great migration from the LES to Kew Gardens, Queens, and then, in 1960 with 2 little boys to Merrick, Long Island. She used to like to tell the story that she voted for JFK in the morning, and moved in that afternoon.

She and my dad lived in the house in Merrick for over 40 years, raising 2 sons, and seeing us marry and bring 5 grandchildren into her and my father’s lives.  She went back to teaching, both in our synagogue’s Hebrew School and in the local Merrick elementary school, retiring after many years without ever making it out of 5th grade. My folks then continued the migration south Florida in 2004.

My father died in 2008, and my mother entered the next chapter of her life. While her world shrank because of the loss of friends and loss of hearing, she seemed content.

Finally, because of illness, we brought her to NY for care. She rallied after a long struggle, and moved into assisted living up here, only to succumb ultimately to the complications of a series of falls.

My mother was, in many ways, a school teacher in and out of the classroom. She had a lot of rules in her class, most of which applied at home as well. She was, she would often say, “strict but fair.” She made sure that idle students (or idle sons) were always engaged in something productive. You did not want to hear my mother ask, “Nothing to do?”

It is impossible to paint a picture of my mother without talking about the great dark cloud that hovered over her head. My mother had a life-long struggle with recurrent major depression. I had her in mind when I wrote recently of the need to talk more openly about mental illness. I did not share her story then, only because she could not consent, and I did not want to violate her privacy.

While my mother avoided the early cancer deaths that took both her parents in their 50s, she was hospitalized many times over the years – the first when my brother and I were just little kids, and most recently this year, which started the cascade that ultimately led to her death. In many ways large and small, her depression shaped her and our entire family. In fact, it was only after overcoming the bout of depression that overtook her after my father died that she seemed to gain serenity and contentment that often seemed to elude her earlier in life.

She was, also, in many ways, a woman of her time. Smart and academically accomplished, she became a teacher because that’s what women did in 1949. She stopped working when my older brother was born, and only returned to full time teaching when I was in 6th grade, because that’s what women did. She managed the household, balanced the checkbook, cooked the meals, took us to the doctor and directed my parents’ social life, because that‘s what women did.

How will I remember her?

I will try hard to blot out the long, painful journey she traveled this year.

I will try instead to think of her as she was over the preceding years, when she would travel to New York for Passover and Thanksgiving, and how we had fallen into a routine of doing something special on the Friday after Thanksgiving before she went back down to Florida.

One year going to the Tenement Museum and sharing a pastrami sandwich at Katz’s Deli on Houston Street.

One year touring the Eldridge Street Synagogue and having lunch at the Harvard Club.

One year visiting her parents’ graves for what she knew to be her last time.

Or, just this last Thanksgiving, having lunch in the city with my family, and then joining my brother and his wife for a matinee performance of Fiddler on the Roof.

Like Fiddler’s Tevya, my mother struggled with change and, in some ways, with modernity. But like him, she ended her struggle in a better place.

May she rest in peace.



16 thoughts on “Charlotte Nash

  1. Hi Ira—

    My sincerest condolences.


    Barry Cohen, M.D.
    Northwell Health
    Physician Partners
    North Shore Internal Medicine
    560 Northern Blvd. Suite 203
    Great Neck, N.Y. 11021

  2. A beautiful testament to your mother, Dr. Nash. Thank you for sharing her story as a real person with human struggles. May you be comforted in your loss.

  3. Dr. Nash,

    My sincerest condolences on your loss. It is clear that your mother was a wonderful woman and she has left you with beautiful memories.

    Jerry Weiner

  4. I can’t comprehend just how sad you must feel
    For the loss of someone you love.
    This sorrowful time must still feel unreal
    And you’re looking for strength from above.

    I hope, from my heart, that your pain will decrease,
    That your spirit will gain strength again,
    And I pray that your faith will create inner peace
    And that God will send blessings–Amen.

    Till then, if you need me to lighten your load,
    I’m waiting to come to your aid.
    Just call on me, and I’ll walk down that road,
    Until the dark times start to fade.

    Deep condolences,

    Poem By Karl Fuchs

  5. Dr. Nash: Your words convey a wonderful sense of what your mother truly was in life. Mothers are all national treasures and their memory helps us to get through life. My deepest condolences.

  6. Thank you for sharing Dr. Nash. Our deepest condolences to you and your family. Your words are a beautiful tribute to your mother.


    Lloyd and Chantal

Join the Discussion! Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s