Physician burnout has received a lot of well-deserved attention lately. Characterized by emotional exhaustion and professional frustration, it has been tied to array of bad outcomes, from physician suicide to poor patient outcomes. Organizations are waking up to the need to measure its prevalence and ameliorate its impact.

There seem to be two broad schools of thought about the causes – and by extension, the fixes – of physician burnout.

The first is focused on the inner life of the physician. Yes, the demands of medical practice are high, but if doctors were a little more “zen” about things, then life would be better for them and the people around them, including their patients. There is now a substantial cottage industry peddling retreats, wellness classes, yoga and more to help physicians find inner peace in our tumultuous times.

The second school of thought focuses on the externalities of physician practice. Increasing demands for productivity, economic stress, loss of control over scheduling, and higher “hassle-factors” associated with EMRs and regulations have made medical practice harder and less rewarding. Burnout is just the natural reaction of sane, well-adjusted, intelligent people put into an insane environment.

Here’s what I think. I do believe that the life of practicing physicians is often difficult, but that doesn’t seem to me sufficient to explain what is going on. Medical practice has always been demanding of physicians’ time and emotional energy. But I also don’t believe that physicians of today are weaker or whinier than their predecessors. So what’s going on?

I think that the root of burnout is the transformation of medical practice from a solitary craft to an industrial process.  This has lead to two related consequences. The first is that the current generation of mature physicians is suffering from a “bait and switch.” The world they signed up for when they began their medical training is not the world they inhabit professionally. The second is a widespread belief among physicians that we have lost our professional autonomy, and thus burnout is a manifestation of profound loss.

So here’s my assessment and plan. I don’t think that “old world” is coming back, and I don’t believe physicians have or should surrender their professional autonomy. Rather, physicians can and should shape the world that takes its place, by asserting their collective professional autonomy to design systems of care that work better for physicians and their patients.

What do you think?

17 thoughts on “Burnout

  1. As with many practices, our group is wrestling with evidence of burnout. Your post mentions the theme of “professional autonomy.” What does that mean? Is the definition from 30 years ago outmoded for 2016?

  2. Eu não sei se seria só comigo ou se talvez alguém encontrou algum problema
    com seu artigo. Parece como se que alguns dos textos escritos em seu conteúdo está aparecendo fora da tela.

    Pode outra pessoa por favor comentar para eu saber se isso está
    acontecendo só comigo. Isto poderia ser um
    erro com meu navegador web, eu vi acontecer a mesma coisa com outro
    blog outro dia. Grato! https://www.bacharelemteologia.club/contato/

Join the Discussion! Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s